Skip to content

Village or City

Last Updated
Moderation & Curation
Propose a change

The Design Problem

When building a new platform (e.g., a social network), it is hard to make design decisions about features and workflows that fit a variety of users, use cases, and contexts. Decentralized technologies often want to be “forked” and implemented by many different and vibrant communities. This means that there won’t be a unifying way to describe user groups and their needs, and the design process can feel “stuck”.

The Design Solution

Instead of thinking specifically about user groups and their needs, consider the feeling or atmosphere you want to create. What kinds of interactions do you want to see? If it’s more like a village, you’ll have close connections with everyone you talk to. Think of a texting app, or an invite-only chat room. If it’s more like a city (think Twitter), your users will have more interactions with strangers.

Some users will want to be in a village in certain contexts; but some communities may want to feel more like cities. Making sure your assumptions about village or city is built into your platform will help users understand the kinds of interactions that are possible and appropriate. Consider patterns like cautious optimism to allow users to opt-in to discovering new users safely.

If you envision a city-like platform, make posts public and anonymous by default - people are used to random and rude behavior in cities. But if you are building a village-like platform, people will expect posts to be shared within a smaller and safer group.

This aspect also affects community growth. For example, communities that are invite-only will feel more like villages. The more controls you create around who is allowed to issue invites (e.g., only moderators/admins or everyone) will further restrict community growth. Give users and moderators clear controls on how to grow their communities. Utilize patterns like social radius slider and content curators to give fine-grained control over social feeds.


Why Choose Village or City?

When you are building an application that relies heavily on social interaction.

Best Practice: How to Implement Village or City

  • Guidelines and parameters regarding community size and interactive elements must be communicated clearly.

Potential Problems with Village or City

It can cause more cognitive load to have more choices in moderation, community interaction, and growth. Decide on where you fall on the “Village or City?” spectrum and make consistent design decisions throughout. Create default settings or an in depth onboarding flow that helps moderators and users understand what the implications are for community openness, public visibility, and invitation rules.

The Take-Away

Users will feel more grounded and active on your platform when community boundaries are clear and aligned with what they are looking for.

References & Where to Learn More

Run Your Own Social